Hip Talk Forum About Hip Resurfacing

Hip Resurfacing General Questions => Hip Resurfacing Topics => Topic started by: othepain4 on December 06, 2011, 08:27:37 PM

Title: eating over exercise
Post by: othepain4 on December 06, 2011, 08:27:37 PM
Has anybody heard of any weight limits for BHR? I weighed 285lbs. on my first 4 years ago. I am now 315. I know the weight doesn't help but between working a lot and not feeling good it has been a lot easier to grab comfort food over exercise!
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: curt on December 07, 2011, 08:45:24 AM
     Don't think there is a "limit" per se.   Think it is probably a surgeons' call based upon risk to the femur during recovery.  Doc should be able to tell you with a call.  Good luck with it,  Curt
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: Dannywayoflife on December 07, 2011, 02:26:47 PM
As above but really the more weight that you can shift the less strain you put on your shinny new joint.
I know that it's hard not to pile on the pounds when your feeling down. I've struggled with depression over the last year and as a result I went from 180 to 225. Just over a year ago I was mega fit and in proper fighting shape. Now I'm in the worst shape of my life! But I'll get it back!!   
Danny
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: Boomer on December 07, 2011, 02:36:47 PM
If you can lose some weight with the guidance of your doctor before surgery, you should so. Keep your strength, but shed the unneeded pounds. After surgery, your operated legs doesn't cooperate very well, so you need to move with your arms and your other leg. The less weight you have to lift in and out of bed, a chair, the toilet etc, the easier it will be for you. You can use that saved energy for your recovery.
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: othepain4 on December 08, 2011, 07:55:53 PM
Good time to go on a diet. Will need help getting to frig. Looking forward to feeling good again!
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: chris finn on December 09, 2011, 01:24:49 PM
Quote from: othepain4 on December 06, 2011, 08:27:37 PM
Has anybody heard of any weight limits for BHR? I weighed 285lbs. on my first 4 years ago. I am now 315. I know the weight doesn't help but between working a lot and not feeling good it has been a lot easier to grab comfort food over exercise!

Maybe the BHR doesnt have a weight limit......but your heart does.
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: Tin Soldier on December 09, 2011, 07:17:24 PM
Not to support weight gain, but it seems that the larger components could support more weight, right?  The more surface area, the more weight something can support, like fat tires on a bog.  Although I have no idea if that is taken into consideration by the surgeon.   I suspect the component size is based solely on bone structure and size.  All I'm getting at is that I don't think there is the potential for dramatic failure or even excessive wear with weight gain.  I'd still try to loose some weight and I'd also talk to the surgeon. 
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: ScubaDuck on December 09, 2011, 09:04:18 PM
Quote
Maybe the BHR doesnt have a weight limit......but your heart does.

Chris, are you saying that I can't love a fat woman?   ;D
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: chris finn on December 10, 2011, 03:28:34 AM
Quote from: DGossack on December 09, 2011, 09:04:18 PM
Quote
Maybe the BHR doesnt have a weight limit......but your heart does.

Chris, are you saying that I can't love a fat woman?   ;D

lol....."If I had me a woman that was big n fat, Id jump up and down like an alley cat" .....as a wise man once sang  ;) ...aint nothing wrong with big women  ;D
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: Dannywayoflife on December 10, 2011, 07:31:52 AM
Quote from: Tin Soldier on December 09, 2011, 07:17:24 PM
Not to support weight gain, but it seems that the larger components could support more weight, right?  The more surface area, the more weight something can support, like fat tires on a bog.  Although I have no idea if that is taken into consideration by the surgeon.   I suspect the component size is based solely on bone structure and size.  All I'm getting at is that I don't think there is the potential for dramatic failure or even excessive wear with weight gain.  I'd still try to loose some weight and I'd also talk to the surgeon.
Tin I think the component sizes are determined mainly by the diameter of your femoral neck. Could be wrong tho
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: PistolPete on December 10, 2011, 07:11:07 PM
When is your surgery?  I really think you should do yourself a huge benefit and try losing as much weight as possible now and for the future.  Don't lose the weight only for your surgery do it to live a healthier lifestyle.
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: othepain4 on December 11, 2011, 06:25:57 PM
My surgery is this Thursday!  I am ready to make changes in my eating habits. I had gone from 346 to 240 before my RBHR a couple of years ago. I had taken up running before my hip acted up. I can't wait to get back into the gym again.
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: hernanu on December 12, 2011, 10:15:38 AM
Sounds like you know how to drop the weight, and that's important, but as you already have seen, recuperating the hip goes first - make sure that's important. As several folks have posted here, good nutrition will help you heal and drop weight.
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: PistolPete on December 12, 2011, 11:56:38 AM
I agree with hern.  After my surgery my diet went to crap as well but I just didn't have much of an appetite so I wasn't eating much.  This was good as I actually dropped a few pounds.  Now, i'm 5 weeks out and eating healthy and back in the gym going easy but feeling good.  My goal is to be down around 6% bodyfat by summer. 

Also, as Hern said your most important goal starting Thursday is your recovery so put that first and weight loss 2nd.  Both work work hand and hand so hang in there.  Also, post surgery now you have both hips done so it's time to celebrate and get your body back on track.
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: Dan L on December 12, 2011, 01:58:46 PM
The first thing my surgeon said after looking at my plain films was to lose weight.  The increasing pain over the following spring and summer underscored that for me, and the MRI confirmed the need for the operation a couple months later.  I was able to fairly easily, for me, lose about 11% of my body weight prior to the surgery in October, lowest I've been since late teens.  By eliminating salt and alot of red meat, smaller portions, replacing things with whole grains, fruit, less starch and generally avoiding crap I shouldn't have been eating for the past 30 years anyway, I made great progress (for me) over 6 months.  I mostly wanted to assure I never have to go through this surgery again and the less weigt on the device, the longer it should last.

It made a huge difference when on crutches not carrying that weight around, and my BP, and other general health metrics all improved also, so I think it was the best possible thing I could have done to prepare.
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: othepain4 on December 12, 2011, 06:50:11 PM
I am looking forward to a healthier lifestyle.I really have no excuse. I enjoy exercise as well as "good" food. I wonder how soon I can get on a exercise bike?
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: papalagidiver on December 12, 2011, 09:51:18 PM
Check out the book The 4-Hour Body by Tim Ferriss . I  realize that this is just another diet book  but worked great for me. I lost 50 pounds getting ready for the surgery and did not exercise since my hip was killing me. Also, it deals with lots more than just dieting.
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: othepain4 on December 14, 2011, 01:26:41 PM
thank you  I think I'll put it on my Christmas list.  Just found out I don't have to be at hospital untill 11  Wanted to get it over with
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: cwg on December 14, 2011, 02:50:32 PM
Dr Steven Gundry's book- He is a top cardio surgeon who wrote a book that makes perfect sense- Its essentially greens only and protein, no fruit, the first two weeks- Easy easy fast safe weight losing. The book is "Evolution something.." and facinating, not just another diet book. My mates who went on it for health reasons have had rapid and shocking results.
And the thinking behind it, and some of the stuff he shares about himself and his patients his really great reading.

You can always exercise something, even if not cardio to get stronger.Weights, bands etc.

Oh, when are you going in for surgery?
I had my BHR and the day after was 5 minutes on a woosey exercise bike in the hospital "gym".

Good luck with everything!
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: Luanna on December 14, 2011, 03:04:19 PM
My hubby and I are following (most of the time) Dr. Gundry's - Diet Evolution diet. My hubby who has a very hard time losing weight has dropped 20 pounds slowly so far. After the holidays he plans on going back on the diet for more weight loss. I do it because it makes me feel great - no processed sugar and very few carbs - mostly veges and a bit of protein and a small amount of fruit. 

He has amazing credentials but at first I thought what he was saying was a lot of "hula hula". The diet works.

Luanna
Title: Re: eating over exercise
Post by: PistolPete on December 14, 2011, 10:05:38 PM
These diets are very similar to the South Beach Diet.  High protein and low to no carbs.  Be careful with these diets because your body needs carbs esp. if you are exercising.  The thought is that when your body doesn't have carbs it will simply burn fat for energy because it doesn't have the carbs to go to.  What really happens with these diets is you simply eat fewer calories because it's almost impossible to overeat on Protein.  Think about eating a grilled chicken slab.  You can only eat so much.  Now, think of eating a bag of chips.  They are carbs and you can eat them until the bag is gone.