Hello Everyone,
I am currently 8 days out of surgery, (12/16/11). Since my first attempt at walking, I have had, what I describe as popping in my hip. I have yet to ask my physician about it, in the hopes that it will subside before my first post-op appt. I have yet to start workin g with my PT but because they are friends, I asked them if this was common. My BHR will be their first experience so they do really no if it is common. Therefore, I come to my new family. On each stride, I have a distinctive three pops. It is my goal to get lots of excercise but this fatigues and irritates my hip. I am a former athlete so i am used to fighting through discomfort so this has prevented me from calling my physician. I guess you could call it machismo or toughing it out. Long story short, Have you experienced any popping in your new joint and how long should i expect that it will be present?
I am eager to read your responses,
Memphis Rob
It sounds like what's called "clunking" it's very normal and is the supporting structures not being tight enough to hold everything in place it will pass soon mate.
Thanks Danny, I needed that. I hope the other replies will ease my fears as well
I found it a really weird sensation not painful but uncomfortable. I got a popping sensation today in the pool with some of the exercises I was doing and I'm 6 weeks and 2 days post op.
Danny
Dr Su told me the same thing Danny wrote. It should pass.
It's a very common thing, comes from the weakness of the stabilizing muscles on your hip. As you get stronger, and they stabilize it grows much less frequent and eventually goes away. I still have the occasional pop at one year plus.
Still, if anything bugs you, talk to the doctor; we'll gladly help, but theres a lot of tough folks here that have nooo problem calling the doctor.
Hello Everyone!
Merry Christmas Eve!
Thought I'd get in on this one as I'm now about nine and a half weeks into getting to know my BHR and have noticed the popping, clunking, clicking (or whatever it is) MORE frequently during the last few days. Most recently just standing at the kitchen sink with weight shifting as I leaned forward and back to operate the faucet. I've heard the "shifting tendon" theory as well...does that cause a distinct, but not painful, movement sensation? Any of your helpful personal observations would be appreciated!
Thanks, Bruce
Bruce I think I know the movement sensation your describing. It's a weird thing and hard to describe but I'm told it's nothing to worry about.
Danny
I've noticed a knock today it's defiantly something that's catching and then releasing. I think it's defiantly because I'm trying as much as possible to push myself and walk and move more. My surgeon said I should try and move as much as possible. I think it will take several months for all the structures to recover and get used to everything.
Thanks Danny!
Walking is not an issue at all for me...just have noticed it much more frequently in the last few days while maneuvering around the house doing normal stuff! No pain, just unsettling. I'll be seeing the Physical Therapist again 12/28. We'll see what her thoughts are. She's BHR savvy!
Happy New Year!
Bruce
As everyone else has noted is normal and it does decrease; now almost 12 weeks post op and it is increasingly rare for me (and was not very frequent to begin with). Disconcerting the first time you feel it for sure, but the Hippians here allayed my fears in short order (these folks are fantastic).
Keep the faith, it'll all better over time for most people.
Dan
In Memphis I take it? Did you do your surgery locally?
I still get the clunk once in awhile, mostly when shifting wait. I've gotten used to it.
Hello Memphis Rob!
Hope I didn't hijack your thread!? The reason I got in on it was because my clunking, snapping, clicking or clacking seemed to be INCREASING when I posted on the 24th! Turns out I apparently "rotated my sacrum" a little bit and that's what is causing my sensation(s) that emanates from my right (operated) hip. My physical therapist worked on me for awhile and it has mostly disappeared!
I'm not saying that's what you are experiencing necessarily, just that there can be more than one cause.
Sorry if I stepped on your toes! Have a Happy New Year!
Bruce
Hey everyone. As you all informed me it would, the popping has decreased significantly. My PT says that I am making great strides. I am using a cane 75% of the time and walking without assistence the other 25. My major concern to date is the Fred G Sanford wobble that I have. My PT says its attributed to the weak muscles that need to be rebuilt. My new question to all of you is how soon can I reasonably expect to be wobbleless?
I would say it was about five weeks for me. It got progressively better so it is hard to say exactly. Then the limp will slowly get better. It is amazing how weak some of the small muscles around the hip are months after surgery. I have been working diligently to strengthen those.
Best wishes.
Dan
I ditched my walking aids after 4 weeks & was a bit wobbly to start with but each day got better. I still work hard on my gait and it's pretty good now at 7 weeks. Listen to your body & take it easy... it's early days mate.
Also had clicking which started about the same time as you. I too was concerned, but as the folk here said it is very common - search "clunking" on this site & you'll see several threads on the topic. I still get it from time to time with certain movements, but the hip capsule is getting stronger.
My advice - get in the pool as soon as you're cleared to - usually this is when the incision is scab free. But consult your doc.
Cherz
Kiwi
Hello again. the clunking is gone. my limp is only present when my pt works me til exhaustion. i am totaly happy with my progress. This is amazing. My only problem is that I now have bee diagnosed with advanced athritis in my opposite knee due to the favoring over the years. doc said he is going to try and get a couple more years out of my existing knee. It bites to be 40 with a new hip and in need of a new knee.
Thanks for your support
Iron congrats on your great progress! Im sorry your knee isn't great tho hope that you can resolve that too.
Glad that things are going well with your hip, Rob.
I know someone who I work with who got a knee resurfacing. He actually recovered pretty quickly, and is doing fine now. I have NO knowledge about this, was just comparing notes (no, we didn't do the macho thing and compare incision scars --- but I would have crushed him) and he seemed pretty happy with it.
Also have "weak" knees. Already did arthroscopic on both for cleaning them up and removing torn meniscus tissue. Aware of three knee interventions: knee replacement; partial knee replacement and arthroscopic surgery for smoothing the rougher areas. A more recent surgery is using a dental type drill to make hundreds of holes in the femur and tibia ends to cause them to "leak" or ooze boney material that mimicks articulate cartilage that protects the bone ends from the bone-on-bone contact. Down-side is that you are completely non-load bearing for 6 weeks. Crutches only. It does not allow full impact but does offer relief from the OA pain.
At six week checkup with Dr. Gross I asked him to evaluate my knees and he stated that arthroscopic would do me zero good and because my knees had medial bone on bone, a partial knee was out, and a total knee drastically limits higher end activity. He recommended doing nothing surgically until I basically can't take it.
Right now my knees are my weakest link in my hip recovery as they too try to remember how to be increasingly active. As my impact increases in my workouts the muscles are sore, but the knee joints are recovering quicker with the help of a few Alleve. Good luck, but its part of getting older I guess. As I tell my friends, "my hip feels great, its the rest of me that feels like &*%%$!"
Curt
Hi Curt,
I don't know much about knee replacements, but in terms of limiting higher end activity levels, here are some of my observations. Here in Sun Valley, there are at least 4 or 5 full time ski instructors, and a similar number of full time ski patrollers who have one or two knee replacements each. Also, one of our local helicopter ski guides who guides heli-skiing all winter, and guides trekking through Nepal, etc, all summer, is about 4 years into his new knee. I think that they do try to avoid bumps, but all of these folks are skiing and active full time. I also had one student who had both knees replaced last year and is back on skis better than in years, and two more students who are having knees replaced this spring.
It is too early to tell how these will work out long term, but all of these folks are happy and active right now.
John, et. al., don't get me wrong. If you can't get around and are impacted severely by knee arthritis, I wouldn't hesitate to have them replaced. That's what led to my hip getting fixed. I would not have hesitated to have a total hip done if HR were not available, but was lucky to have a procedure available that MIGHT have superior longevity. Hope it works. I do trust Dr. Gross enough to shake off the knees until I can't take it anymore, or until a better longevity solution presents itself.
Curt
Thanks John C and Curt. I am using Ibuprofen to alleviate the knee pain. My Doc is suggesting Supartz injections and said this will get bme by on my "God -Given" knees for a few years. I'll be trying it
I hear that they are making quick progress with stem cell treatment. You may want to Check out what they are already doing in Europe. I just heard about this over the weekend so I have researched but the source is in the medical field and needing a knee replacement.
There is a doctor named Kevin Stone who is doing biological knee replacements, and working on "humanizing" animal tissue to make the supply of biologic replacements abundant and cheap.
Check it out: http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/en/kevin_stone_the_bio_future_of_joint_replacement.html (http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/en/kevin_stone_the_bio_future_of_joint_replacement.html)
Can I have the knees of a Jaguar or Cheetah? The rhino ones aren't that good!!
Curt