I like this idea a lot. I was recently looking for info on a doc that has a lot of experience but didn't have a lot of posts about him here. I did a search and found a fair amount of folks that had posted about him, and that worked for me, but the surgeon-specific areas will be a little easier to pull info from.
A quick thought. I am a little concerned about inflamed or even nice, but not accurate info posted about a surgeon. I know Pat has tried hard to keep that sort of junk off this website. Obviously, our experiences, as long as we are honest, are accurate. I guess I just worry that some folks might hear something negative about a surgeon, albeit a small thing, and it gets magnified by discussion and such.
I'm not sure if that can be addressed with a note at the top of the surgeon area, or if it's just a matter of the community keeping an eye on it.
Just my 2 cents. Thanks to Pat and others for all their hard work on this!