I searched NH and northeastern MA for a resurfacing specialist for my brother, who also has BC/BS Anthem insurance, with limited
results. I got lead on Dr. Snyder in Boston and another Dr in RI. Couldn't find enough info on either one, postive or negative.
Sent X-Rays to Dr Gross and Dr Bose, and liked both of those guys and their responses. At the end of all the searching my brother decided his heart was set on Dr. Su in NYC.
A few factors played into his decision:
1) I had just reached the 2 year mark of an LBHR by Dr Su. Ridiculously easy, trouble free recovery.
2) As easy as they make the whole process at HSS, I would accompany him through on pre-op day.
3) He would spend at least 3-5 weeks at my house in North NJ, recovering, hanging out with my kids and being near Dr Su, just in case.
BC/BS approved his procedure, but dear brother didn't look at the fine print. It was approved, but only for about 10% because it was
out of network. The BC/BS rep assigned to my brother's case, advised, after the fact, that any doctor in network would have been totally covered.
Brother will half heartedly appeal it with BC/BS, but does not regret using Dr Su at all and says he would do it the same way again.
Didn't mean to derail your thread, good luck with your appeal. I hope you can find an experienced Dr in network.