This guy is not up to date or at least is not reading carefully the details of the reports that cross his desk.
I had the same thing happen to me. I bet a lot of us did.
Resurfacing has become a smaller, more specialized operation than it was in the early 2000s. It was heralded as the Holy Grail when it first came out. There have been problems and recalls. But the devices still on the market and the docs still doing the operation do a great job. There are articles in peer reviewed journals that support the continued success of resurfacing. (When I was interviewing surgeons, I talked to a really good local guy who did keep up to date and read journals and go to CE. He said that HR had fallen out of favor, but there was this one guy in North (sic) Carolina who had great results...)
As far as running post op, even the old timers I got opinions from let their patients run now. Yep, even the guy who still uses a small head THR device and told me I couldn't cross my legs post op told me I could run, but it might cause my THR to wear out sooner.
Get some more opinions. Read more here. I don't think there is a one size fits all solution. Figure out what will fit your lifestyle, age, physical condition, and (sorry to say) budget.