Hi
Welcome to hip talk. I don't know where this surgeon found his information, but it is not consistent with any other published information I have seen in 4 years.
It is true that women under 50 can have more problems than men, but it is not a 25% failure rate. It is also true that women that are large boned that use the larger sized BHR and hip resurfacing devices have the same outcome as men. I have the Australian National Registry posted here with that info
http://www.surfacehippy.info/aoanationalreg08.php and here
http://www.surfacehippy.info/pdf/NJRRAnnRep08.pdfGoodness, not even the worst surgeons in the US have that failure rate. The failure rate worldwide was less than 1% with a survivorship of 99.8%, then when the US surgeons started in 2006, it brought that down to a worldwide suvivorship of 96%. That included men and women.
http://www.surfacehippy.info/bhrhistory.phpSurgeons that are against resurfacing tend to find some very strange information which is not normally public and OFTEN incorrect. I can only tell you that I have many hundreds of personal sucess stories on my website. My own BHR is now almost 4 years old and I had mine at 61. I know a handful of older women with sucessful hip resurfacing.
What surgeon are you considering using? You should ask your own surgeon what the survival rate is. Trust me, US surgeons in our sue crazy country would never do procedures that had a 25% failure rate! This information is just not correct. Maybe is it from some obscure surgeon that only did 4 resurfacings and had 1 failure - then quit resurfacing. I know of no surgeon with that kind of failure rate in the US or overseas. Remember, the BHR and resurfacings has been done overseas since 1997. My own surgeon, De Smet of Belgium, has now done way over 3000 resurfacings and some surgeons have done way over 4000 overseas.
Please take some time to read more information, talk to the folks here and ask your own surgeon for information. If he is one of the really experienced surgeons I have on my list, he/she will definitely set the record straight.
Pat