This is my first post, but I've learned a lot from this site. So thanks to Pat Walter and everyone who has contributed to my education.
Here's my story (I hope it's not too long). After some difficulty trying to choose the right surgeon (I live in Argentina) I had my left hip resurfaced by a local doctor about a year and a half ago. I blamed early difficulties with movability and pain on my own weaknesses, and by 6 months post-op I was rock climbing again, hiking regularly and generally getting as much activity as I could. However I was having problems. For one thing, in spite of increased flexibility lifting my leg behind, I experienced very reduced flexibility lifting my leg in front. To this day I have to cross my leg under my butt to put on a sock. A more serious problem was recurring pain when putting weight on my resurfaced hip. Each time I thought I was over the hump and on the way to full recovery, I would get sore again and revert to limping around for a week or two. During the first 10 months, I tried to convince myself the implant was fine. All I needed was time to work it through. But I certainly had suppressed doubts. At any rate, one insomnolent night, I found an article on line by Dr. Koen De Smet et. al. considering the relation between the cup's abduction angle and metal ion counts in the blood, that showed how to measure the angle by drawing a reference line. So I went to my post-op x-ray and measured. The angle was a good 65 degrees. I suppose everyone around here knows what that means.
It was clear I needed a blood test for metal ions ASAP. Thanks to this site, I decided to contact Dr. Koen De Smet and Dr.Thomas Gross by e-mail for some initial advice. They were both kind enough to answer. As De Smet put it: "indeed the version and steepness are quite incorrect! It would be good to have your metal ions chequed". So we did. But the test came back absolutely normal ... for someone who doesn't have a MOM implant. I couldn't believe it, so we did another test at a different lab. Normal again. At this point my own doctor was pretty useless, and my wife and I decided he didn't have a clue. Because of the low metal count, I decided to let things slide and see how it would go.
For the next 6 months I went through ups and downs. There were times when I thought things were really getting better, but every time I would get hit with another set back and revert to limping around in pain. We found a hip doctor who had a good reputation in Buenos Aires and went to see him. I was curious if he would recognize immediately the poorly placed cup (he did) and what he might say. After looking at one x-ray the guy wanted to do revision surgery. A new twist was the doctor thought the cup was coming loose. By this point I was resigning myself to the need for revision (after a year and a half I was once again back to limping around in pain) but I still wanted to know what my problem was. Looseness (if that were true) did not explain it. And my metal ion count was still completely normal. Once again it was time to contact the big guns. So I wrote to Dr. Gross and Dr. De Smet again, sending a description of my symptoms, data on implant make and size. etc. and a battery of x-rays. Dr. De Smet was the first to give me a diagnosis. He started his e-mail by writing in caps, just like this: "DEAR TIM, YOU HAVE NORMAL IONS BECAUSE YOU ARE WALKING YOUR OWN BONE INSTEAD OF THE CUP". This made perfect sense to me. We had seen from x-rays that the offset cup was apparently letting the femoral component contact hip bone. My wife had suggested this could be causing my problems. Since my pain and limitations where not unlike the problems of bone on bone from osteoarthritis, hers seemed like the best explanation so far. When De Smet said this was also causing the low ion count, I knew that was right. Holy moly: for a year and a half I'd been walking on hip bone instead of the implant!
So now I'm off to Belgium to try and get fixed. Dr. De Smet told me cup revision was less certain to work out, but if I wanted to do impact sports it could be worth the risk. So we went for it. If the cup revision can't be done, De Smet will be ready with a large head ceramic on ceramic THR.
Wish me luck and I'll let you know how this works out when I get back in March.