OK. Here's my answer to this post.
Having not had a resurfacing, I might make myself unpopular by going against the grain. BUT, this is just my decision for my body.
I was diagnosed February 2011 at 36 years old with left hip OA. A year previously I started to have very mild groin pain just when training grappling/BJJ and getting into my car. From March 2011 I started to have much more pain walking/standing all the time because I let my left leg/glute atrophy to let some quadracepts tears heal.
After a couple of rounds of quality physical therapy, I can honestly say I am FAR better off than 11 months ago. However, the daily pain has never completely gone away. If I miss the right strengthening in the right combinations, I have pain just walking, standing in the shower, and milling about the house. However, if I strengthen properly I am pretty much fine for daily activity.
I still have a plan to get back to running even with this OA at least recreationally. I can do this because I trust my physical therapist.
I am NOT going for a hip resurfacing now for the following reasons:
1. The longer I wait, the better the chance of stem cell or cartilage repair treatment. Unlikely, but an opportunity worth maximazing.
2. The longer I wait, the better the stats on BHR longevity, the effects of various impacts, and ways to extend/protect longevity.
3. Waiting now pushes back the time a BHR of mine will ever (potentially) need revision, and thus gives more time for better post-BHR alternatives to develop.
4. I get to enjoy the fact that I have my own, natural God-given hip. Yes, it is generally deteriorating, and I'm not as able bodied as I was a couple years ago. But I'm in minimal pain most of the time and have good reason to expect I'll be able to get back to most sports, albeit with modifications, for years go come.
5. Waiting longer allows a greater span of time to benefit from medications in development that may slow the rate of enzyme production that limits fixation.
6. Vijay Bose just keeps getting better and better, more experienced and more experienced!
7. Any major invasive surgery in which my body is cut open for 5 hours has its risks. I'd rather not take those risks any sooner than necessary.
8. X-Rays and MRIs are excellent ways of monitoring the joint to ensure I don't wait too long.
9. More information about long term metal ions becomes available over time.
10. Synvisc, cortison, and medications... gotta buy a couple of years.
11. Global catastrophe and economic collapse look unlikely! BHRs aren't going anywhere!
So there you have it. My personal assumptions and why I choose to wait. Time is on my side.
Note: I'm fortunate in that I have been informed by several top surgeons my hip does not yet need resurfacing. Others might be in a different situation!