I could see where tolerances if they are off some could cause issues, I guess it could even cause an implant to seize up? Who knows for sure, but I have heard the same thing regarding tolerances. Most devices today use a tolerance so that your synovial fluid acts as the lubricant like a piston in an engine, the device rides on the fluid as opposed to the metal to metal contact.
Off the record I've heard a number of doctors say that it's not the implant, it's the technique used to get it in place properly. Dr. Rogerson was pretty open to that fact on a recent chat and he's a very good hippie doctor.
I hope everyone does not get me wrong, when I hear the chest thumping that "my doctor/device is the best" I actually get a really good feeling inside, because I know that it's just one more successful surface hippy and that is certainly an awesome thing, especially since I am acutely aware of how much pain I went through. It's natural to think that your doctor is "THE BEST!", especially when you hear of so many good results.
BTW--- I know Dr. Gross is the best hip surgeon in the US.
Chuck