** Disclaimer: I am not a doctor, I don't play one on TV. My statements are a combination of personal pre-op research, my own rehab and a HUGE dose of opinion based on my own deductions. I think there is a lot of interpretive gray area all over the theories of proper rehab.
That said, there are certain constants I believe hold true for all patients:
1.
Fact: The acetabular cup has been press-fit into the hip bone. There is no glue. The knurled back allows for bony in-growth over time. This is the "glue" that will hold it in place so that it can withstand the pressures of activity. The key phrase here is "over time". Bone growth is slow. During the first 6 months to a year (depending on what surgeon you ask), this bony in-growth is not complete and, therefore, not a completely solid bond.
My Opinion: Significant pressure on this cup (what I have referred to as "torquing") early on can make it move in the socket. I think of it as gluing something and then twisting the parts before the glue is dry and it comes loose. Not only is the glue probably not going to ever permanently bond the two pieces because of this movement, they are now misaligned, and probably going to continue to move around, preventing any future bonding. You now have a permanent failure of the mechanism.
2.
Fact: During the surgery, the femoral vascular system is temporarily disrupted. Over the next (approximately) 3 months, the bone density of the upper femur, including the femoral head, weakens as the body rebuilds the supply damage within the femur. The theoretical peak of this weakness is supposedly at the 3 month mark. From month 3 to month 6 (or month 12, depending upon what surgeon you ask), the density slowly gets better and better. Some of the research documentation suggested that in many cases, the density after one year was actually better than before surgery. I believe that they attributed this to a higher level of activity post-op than pre-op for those who were significantly immobile before surgery. Moderate impact (AFTER THE HEALING PERIOD) keeps bone density up.
My opinion: Pretty much the same as #1 - Any high pressure on the femoral head when it is in this weakened state could subject it to breakage. This danger is two-pronged. You also can engage in activities that risk trauma (falling off a bike or while skiing) during the "weak" period that will snap the femoral head off like a toothpick. This I know as a good friend of mine did exactly that. A very light fall from a bike at about 3 months and it snapped.
So, what exactly is the right amount of effort to get the muscles and body back while not risking the device or the femur? From what I can gather, nobody knows. And I am sure we have all heard the tired cliche "Listen to your body." It's not the body I don't trust, its the mind drowning it out with a lot of "I want, I want, I want" whining. Face it, we are all a bunch of overgrown, spoiled 5 year olds who want what we want...NOW!
I think there are obvious no-no's of high impact that we have all heard. If you don't know what these are, you haven't done your homework and need to stay after school to catch up with the rest of the class.
Personally, I didn't do anything that put a high resistance on the joint: leg weightlifting, hard bike resistance, any upper-body weights that put twisting leverage on my core. I strongly feel you should not put either hard pressure nor leveraged twisting on the joint in the healing period.
There are two points I'd like to make here:
1. I know from over 30 years of strength training that you can fully work you soft tissue (muscles) without having to use huge weights that put a lot of pressure on the joints. High reps with very low weight taken to muscle fatigue is very effective.
2. YOU ARE NOT TRAINING, YOU ARE HEALING. I think that this point is being missed by many. Yes, this operation is so you can get back to doing everything - AFTER YOU HEAL. Nobody said you can do everything as soon as you check out of the hospital. If you insist on acting like a spoiled 5 year old and do something impulsively stupid, your hip will punish you like an angry nun in catholic school.
Everyone must do what they feel is right for them. Personally, I gave up some overall fitness and did a very conservative rehab to give myself the best chance of success with the device. I realized that all I had to do was face the fact that it is all ego. I have been in Ironman shape for over 20 years, and I didn't want to lose that. Boo Hoo. Once I got over myself and this whole B.S. about tying a good deal of my identity to my fitness lifestyle, I realized that I wasn't losing that lifestyle. I was moving through a phase of my lifestyle that required the same amount of discipline it took to get there in the first place. And I would work with both my body and my common sense so that I could achieve this goal just like all the other goals that came before.
If ever a cliche fit this situation I think this one does:
"Train smarter, not harder."
Best to all my fellow hippies. Please take care of yourselves.