Hi Rosie
I'm female, 40 and in the UK. I had a resurfacing in 2003 which is doing well despite pain this year which turned out to be referred from the other hip. My surgeon is no longer doing resurfacings. He says that I am a prime example of why they do work and work well in some women but he prefers to do the minihip arthroplasty. I have perfect ion levels, good placement and no issues on the MRI. . My left hip (resurfacing) components are 40mm femoral and 46mm acetabular and my right hip (mini thr) are 36mm and 50mm I think the acetabular component is larger due to a plastic liner. i have no restrictions other than bungee jumping and marathon running although I think my surgeon knows I will be cautious with it as I have no wish to be back on the operating table anytime soon. with my first op he did say how long it lasts is pretty much up to you, I walk, I garden i have done a little jogging but my unoperated hip went on strike for a month so I haven't tried that again. I will one day ski again, ride again and a little mountain biking but nothing too scary. the incapacity was scary enough.
I think the THR is an easier operation and certainly an easier recovery for me this time around. my question about the minihip is longevity, but being a new item there isn't data, I believe in resurfacing, i wanted another but due to my problems not showing up on xray well I needed help and my surgeon was the only one listening to me. He wasn't doing resurfacing so I was having a mini hip or nothing. It is the next best thing and I have still kept a lot of bone for future revisions. The pain i was in meant that i was just incredibly grateful for being operated on.
If you want a resurfacing, I suggest you go to one of the most senior experienced surgeons (2000 resurfacings plus) and get their opinion on whether or not you would be a candidate. Trust them. I do believe it is a better solution and leaves you in a better place for the future if done by the right surgeon. all operations have their statistics of failure, no hip surgery is ever undertaken lightly it is pain that drives you to the surgeon's knife. You just want the odds stacked better in your favour and you can achieve that by doing exactly what you are doing, your own research.
the media are certainly seeming to vilify HR, i can't understand it, i'd rather have the choice as a patient, to conserve more bone. My surgeon pretty much blamed it on the ASR, most devices are very sucessful but that was so poorly designed. some MOM THR are as bad and have been recalled. the Metalosis issues are generally non issues if you have perfect placement although some are unlucky. if you are sensitive to metal then perhaps you should think hard about it but I have topical nickel allergies and as it turns out no hip issues from my 9yr old resurfacing.
I hope you come to a satisfactory conclusion, i'm always around if you want to chat - being a hybrid means that i've experienced both sides of the equation and am now bionic, pain free and grateful. pm me if i can help.
Sal