Not intending to post daily, just when something interesting happens.
So I am doing my due diligence on HR. Reading lots, but also having some face to face conversations with a few local OS and patients. I had an appointment yesterday with a local OS who has 1) operated on several people I know (THR and FAI) and 2) was recommended to me by a nerdy radiologist friend who sees a lot of hips. I didn't tell him what I was thinking, just said I have arthritis in both hips pretty bad and want to explore my options. I brought X-rays.
Two observations:
1) To brag a little, I can still pass the initial clinical tests where ROM and strength are assessed. I can squat and get up unaided, put my shoes on and tie them, walk normally for short distances. I can look good enough for the OS to say "how comprehensive was your last PT? Did they really focus on your core?" And then he sees the X-rays, drops the idea of PT, and tells me I look pretty bad. We come back to "how bad is your pain."
2) He made a good case for THR. This OS is pretty up to date, uses the anterior approach, uses poly on ceramic, largest head possible for my anatomy, gets me up and out of the hospital quickly, knows how to preserve my blood, etc. And....he doesn't give me any limitations. I pressed him hard on this, like will I be able to run, sit cross legged, kayak, do yoga, and he still said that though there are activities he would not recommend, there are none he would forbid. It seemed like he had been reading hiprunner.com. I asked how long my device would last, when would I need a revision if I really went out there and did whatever I wanted. He didn't/couldn't really give me an answer, but said he had a lot of faith in the device and that it could outlast me.
It was a very different response than what I expected.
FWIW I have a friend here in the same city also interviewing OS for a new hip. She is getting the more expected responses: six weeks of restricted activity, then a lifetime ban on high impact sports or face a revision, plus certain moves that are not advised, like sitting with ankle on knee. We are talking to different docs. We are the same age, both trim and active, I am more of an extreme sports girl. Maybe that affects our doctor selection? Maybe I am screening them differently?
So I will talk to some patients and see what they really do and how they really feel. It is easy for surgeons to tell you you will be fully functional. Best to ask patients what they can really do and how they feel. I am deeply skeptical that a THR will last me my whole life if I run on it. Heck, I don't think a resurfacing will last my whole life if I run on it. Am I being too pessimistic?