+-

Author Topic: Biomet Magnum/Recap vs. BHR survival rate  (Read 1607 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

tommyhip

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 16
Biomet Magnum/Recap vs. BHR survival rate
« on: October 25, 2017, 08:16:25 PM »
I have done some research on both BHR and the Biomet prosthesis as used by Dr. Gross. They seem to be similar in metallurgy and some research suggests that they may even be manufactured by the same company. However, the Australia Registry shows a failure rate for Biomet (assuming it's the same two components) as much higher than BHR. Can anyone explain this?  I would appreciate it. 
« Last Edit: October 25, 2017, 08:17:16 PM by tommyhip »

MattJersey

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 213
Re: Biomet Magnum/Recap vs. BHR survival rate
« Reply #1 on: October 26, 2017, 06:03:12 AM »
The device alone isn't the only factor, and may not even be the major factor. Others that come to mind:


Surgeon's skill and experience should contribute to getting the device positioned well. So a poor or poorly experienced surgeon may increase failure risk.


Patient selection: smaller sizes demand great care and precision in placement. Go back to surgeon skill.


Patient selection: hip dysplasia or other patient hip complications (e.g. bone density) may be a critical factor.


Patient compliance with recovery protocol, and subsequent activity levels.




The ASR De Puy device which was a big failure wasn't a total failure for all patients, and maybe underlines the surgeon placement factor in terms of criticality.


I would be comfortable with either the Biomet or the BHR that I have.



And a stupid question, sorry: presumably it is the Biomet resurfacing device, and not other hip replacements (THR devices)? Biomet Magnum may be a THR device with a possible recall (and Biomet then taken over by Zimmer if my quick read is correct). Biomet Conserve is the resurfacing device if memory serves. That might explain the failure rate.


« Last Edit: October 26, 2017, 06:10:38 AM by MattJersey »
28 April 2015, RBHR Mr McMinn

einreb

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 289
Re: Biomet Magnum/Recap vs. BHR survival rate
« Reply #2 on: October 26, 2017, 08:11:43 PM »
I have done some research on both BHR and the Biomet prosthesis as used by Dr. Gross. They seem to be similar in metallurgy and some research suggests that they may even be manufactured by the same company. However, the Australia Registry shows a failure rate for Biomet (assuming it's the same two components) as much higher than BHR. Can anyone explain this?  I would appreciate it.


Its my understanding that the geometry and metallurgy of the two devices is very similar.  Its the uncemented aspect now that would be the biggest difference, but both caps seem to perform well installed correctly.


I looked for the document I had read on the Australian data explanation, but couldn't find it.  The point was that data was more a reflection of having an experienced surgeon rather than the device.  The biomet pool of data was smaller and the data was made up of a bunch of surgeons only doing a few surgeries.


Note... I think that does actually reflect poorly on the Biomet in how they may have rolled out he device or trained the surgeons in Australia.   i.e. you may be better off with a lousy device like the ASR installed by a good surgeon rather than a good device installed by a surgeon not skilled in resurfacing.  But I digress. :)


If you're looking at Dr Gross though, that is somewhat moot since his results are very good.

40yo at the time of my 2/16/2011 left hip uncemented Biomet resurface with Tri Spike Acetabular cup by Gross

Horse rider

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 6
Re: Biomet Magnum/Recap vs. BHR survival rate
« Reply #3 on: November 21, 2017, 11:09:43 PM »
I am scheduled for bilateral surgery in a few weeks with Dr. Gross. Is the feeling of the group that the device he uses are good? I am a 54 year old woman and I want to return to my profession of training horses. Thanks for any thoughts.

Horse rider

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 6
Re: Biomet Magnum/Recap vs. BHR survival rate
« Reply #4 on: November 21, 2017, 11:11:51 PM »
I am a 54 year old woman and am scheduled for bilateral resurfacing with Dr. Gross in a few weeks. Is the general consensus that the device he uses is good?

 

Mission Statement
Surface Hippy presents information about hip resurfacing. It does not provide medical advice.
It is designed to support, not to replace, the relationship between patient and clinician.
Advertising - Revenue from this site is derived from commercial advertising and individual donations. Any advertisement is distinguished by the word "advertisement"
Privacy - Surface Hippy does not share email addresses or personal information with any group or organization.
Content - Surface Hippy is not controlled or influenced by any medical companies, doctors or hospitals.
All content is controlled by Patricia Walter - Joint Health Sites LLC 2005 - 2018 Web design by Patricia Walter.

Hip TalkModeration

Authority

The Hip Talk Discussion Group or forum is moderated on a Daily basis by Patricia Walter.

The moderator and forum members are not regarded as health professionals.

Complementarity

The information provided on this forum is designed to support, not replace, the direct relationship between patients and health professionals.

Privacy

We remind you that this forum is public and any message can be read, used, reproduced and cited by all.
You do have the option to delete your messages. However, under exceptional circumstances, you can contact the moderator to do so. Thus, please take care regarding the information that you post.

Messages

The moderator and members should conduct themselves at all times with respect and honesty.

By using our forums, you agree to post information that is true and correct to the best of your knowledge and is of your personal experience. If the information you post is not personal experience, we request you to provide sources (references, links, etc..) whenever it is relevant and possible.

You are not allowed to post advertisements, whether in the form of text links or banners, for example.

Please keep your comments positive and polite. If you have a disagreement with another forum member, moderator or the site owner; please use the the private message feature of this forum or email the member. We try to avoid emotional conflicts on the discussion group and we will do so by removing posts and banning those that cause problems.

The moderator reserves the right to delete any messages deemed inappropriate without notifying the author. In cases of abuse, the moderator reserve the right to ban a member of the forum. In both instances, an explanation will be provided if user requests.

Recent Posts

Advertisements

Donate Thru Pay Pal

Surface Hippy Gear

Advertisements



Powered by EzPortal