Matty-
I don't think I could say for sure when exactly it stopped. As mentioned dit was always very minor clunking although still disquieting- who wants their body to act strangely?. I would estimate there was still the smallest of echoes of the symptom for close to a year. The second hip is now 16 months and was the hip with the clunking symptom and I can't remember it acting like that since last Nov. or so. I'll tell you by then I had been using the bosu ball at the gym 3-5 times a week- doing a set of 20 squats, then a minute balancing on each leg, then shallow one legged dips with foot forward and behind. This was always my finishing exercise after my work out. I really think these exercises contributed to clearing up some remaining weakness/looseness in the rotators which are the muscles used in the Tailor exercise which is what caused my clunking. Not a scientific analysis but subjectively makes sense. In any case another member here had recommended it and I added it to the recovery program with good results. S I am now 18/16 months out. I was never really a runner but have tried to add some jogging to the treadmill sessions, which up until last week always caused me post exercise grief [the joint felt sore, impacted, resentful]. I always back off when it comes to bad pain- I trust my body too much to ignore what it's saying. Retreat, wait and return which I did last week and to my great relief I was able to add a very small amount of slow 5mph jogging to the session. Oddly it felt better when doing so on a slight incline. There was no discomfort during the jogging and virtually none after [<.25 out of 5]. Last night's good news for me was in the pool. For at least 2 years prior to surgery and until last night the only way I could swim laps was using fins. Prior to surgery the pain of kicking was too much and after using the fins for so long my post surgical kick was non existent. That seems to be turning the corner for me as well. Getting in last night I gave it a shot and the legs seemed to have located their rhythm and strength enough to begin to propel my through the water again without using the fins. It is a long process for some of us- I am not any kind of elite athlete just someone who tries to stay fit and enjoys using their body- my competition days are over. I don't quite remember your goals for the surgery but just keep in mind every step forward without OA is a step in the right direction. At 2 months I was only barely able to walk more than a mile without a cane. Take your time.